Putting Children First

Semi-Finalist for the Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Book Award

"Putting Children First is must reading for anyone making decisions that affect low-income mothers as they struggle to balance work and family responsibilities-in fact, for anyone who cares about the future of children. Ajay Chaudry makes crystal clear the pitfalls of making social policy from an altitude of 50,000 feet. Knowing the facts on the ground is the first step to a sensible child-care system. We have a long way to go, but this book is a great step in the right direction."
-PETER B. EDELMAN, Professor of Law, Georgetown University Law Center

"Ajay Chaudry's Putting Children First is the most insightful and poignant study of the child-care problems of poor single mothers in urban areas that I have read. This book should be required reading not only for students of urban poverty, but also for national policy makers of welfare reform who have yet to address many of the unique challenges of single motherhood in low-income urban neighborhoods."
-WILLIAM JULIUS WILSON, Lewis P. and Linda L. Geyser University Professor, Harvard University

"An honest, poignant ethnography, Putting Children First provides an extraordinary window into the child care worries of poorly paid working mothers who find that good care for their children is unaffordable and scarce. Ajay Chaudry reminds us what it costs to drop the best interests of children from our national policy agenda. Sharp, focused, and wise."
-CAROL STACK, Professor of Social and Cultural Studies in Education, University of California, Berkeley

"Ajay Chaudry skillfully takes us into the reality of the child care struggles of low-income working parents, and the picture is both disturbing and illuminating. The findings will almost certainly alter the reader's thinking about the dilemmas mothers and policy makers face and the strategies for doing better. If one cares about welfare reform, or low-income workers, or most importantly the future of our children, this book is important reading."
-DAVID T. ELLWOOD, Dean and Scott M. Black Professor of Political Economy, John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University

In the five years following the passage of federal welfare reform law, the labor force participation of low-income, single mothers with young children climbed by more than 25 percent. With significantly more hours spent outside the home, single working mothers face a serious childcare crunch—how can they provide quality care for their children? In Putting Children First, Ajay Chaudry follows forty-two low-income families in New York City over three years to illuminate the plight of these mothers and the ways in which they respond to the difficult challenge of providing for their children’s material and developmental needs with limited resources.

Using the words of the women themselves, Chaudry tells a startling story. Scarce subsidies, complicated bureaucracies, inflexible work schedules, and limited choices force families to piece together care arrangements that are often unstable, unreliable, inconvenient, and of limited quality. Because their wages are so low, these women are forced to rely on inexpensive caregivers who are often under-qualified to serve the developmental needs of their children. Even when these mothers find good, affordable care, it rarely lasts long because their volatile employment situations throw their needs into constant flux. The average woman in Chaudry’s sample had to find five different primary caregivers in her child’s first four years, while over a quarter of them needed seven or more in that time.

This book lets single, low-income mothers describe the childcare arrangements they desire and the ways that options available to them fail to meet even their most basic needs. As Chaudry tracks these women through erratic childcare spells, he reveals the strategies they employ, the tremendous costs they incur and the anxiety they face when trying to ensure that their children are given proper care.

Honest, powerful, and alarming, Putting Children First gives a fresh perspective on work and family for the disadvantaged. It infuses a human voice into the ongoing debate about the effectiveness of welfare reform, showing the flaws of a social policy based solely on personal responsibility without concurrent societal responsibility, and suggesting a better path for the future.

AJAY CHAUDRY is a writer on social policy issues and a faculty and senior research fellow in urban policy and management at New School University.