Pious Property
About This Book
"Bill Maurer has a unique talent for communicating the most sophisticated theoretical con cepts in ways that can be brought to bear upon pressing social issues. Pious Property engages with matters of immediate political concern in a way that is both remarkably sensitive to the complexities of the issues and yet always accessible to a broad readership. Along the way, it provides a powerful demonstration of the unique contributions ethnography can make to our understanding of cutting edge policy problems."
-ANNELISE RILES, professor of anthropology and law, Cornell University
"How do Muslims in the United States finance their homes? And by what means, given the religious injunction against interest, do Islamic bankers make mortgages available to their cli ents? In this fascinating, highly accessible new book, Bill Maurer, one of the most imaginative anthropologists of his generation, shows us how the ordinary practice of house-buying illumi nates contemporary Islamic law and, yet more significantly, the cultural citizenship of Muslim Americans in the delicate years since 9/11. Breaking with received social science concepts, Pious Property offers an intriguing analysis of the way in which home finance, filtered through Islam, has acquired a 'charisma of form' at the point of intersection between the religious and secular. In so doing, it succeeds splendidly-and importantly-in unsettling Euro-American stereotypes of Islam and Muslims."
-JOHN COMAROFF, Harold H. Swift Distinguished Service Professor, University of Chicago, and senior research fellow, American Bar Foundation
"Pious Property is a magnificent contribution to the growing literature on Muslims in the United States. Accessible, cogent, and original, by a leading anthropologist of law and society, this book provides valuable insight into the marriage of pragmatism and idealism evident in the expansion of Islamic financial instruments. By touching on the historical debates about the sinfulness of interest-bearing debt in Christian terms, Bill Maurer draws significant parallels and makes sense of how the contemporary context of opportunity (the American dream) conditions the evolution of Muslim practices in the United States. This book will bring the study of American Islam to the fore of mainstream scholarship about the relationship between law, religion, and economics."
-KATHLEEN M. MOORE, associate professor and chair, Law and Society Program, University of California, Santa Barbara
Owning a home has always been central to the American dream. For the more than one million Muslims in the United States, this is no exception. However, the Qur'an forbids the payment of interest, which places conventional home financing out of reach for observant Muslims. To meet the growing Muslim demand for home purchases, a market for home financing that would be halal, or permissible under Islamic law, has emerged. In Pious Property, anthropologist William Maurer profiles the emergence of this new religiously based financial service and explores the ways it reflects the influence of Muslim practices on American economic life and vice versa.
Pious Property charts the development of Islamic mortgages in America, starting with Islamic interpretations of the prohibition against riba—literally translated as "increase" but interpreted as "usury" or "interest." Maurer then explores the different practices that have emerged as permissible options for Islamic homebuyers—such as lease-to-own arrangements, profit-loss sharing, and cost-plus contracts—and explains how they have gained acceptance in the Islamic community by relying on payment schemes that avoid standard interest rate payments. Using interviews with Muslim homebuyers and financiers, and in-depth analysis of two companies that provide mortgage alternatives to Muslims, Maurer discovers an interesting paradox: progressive Muslims tend to use financial contracts that seemingly comply better with the prohibition against interest, while traditional Muslims seem more inclined to take on financing very similar to interest-based mortgages. Maurer finds that Muslims make their decisions about using Islamic mortgage alternatives based not only on the views of religious scholars, but also on their conceptions of how business is supposed to be conducted in America. While one form of Islamic financing is seemingly more congruent with the prohibition against riba, the other exhibits more of the qualities of American mortgages—anonymity and standardized forms. The appearance that an Islamic financing instrument is legal and professional leaves many Muslim homebuyers with the impression that it is halal, revealing the influence of American capitalism on Muslim Americans’ understanding of their religious rules.
The market for halal financial products exists at the intersection of American and Islamic culture and is emblematic of the way that, for centuries, America's newcomers have adapted to and changed the fabric of American life. In Pious Property, William Maurer explores this rapidly growing economic phenomenon with historical perspective and scholarly insight.
BILL MAURER is associate professor of anthropology at the University of California, Irvine.